NBCs the Voice Season 3: Reimaging Britney Spears’ Toxic

Monday night we were treated with a re-imagining of Britney Spears’ Toxic by Melanie Martinez. It was so good it got three of the four judges to turn their chairs: Adam, CeeLo and Blake.

However this isn’t the first time that we have seen a re-imaging of Toxic in recent memory… In fact Jake Wesley Rogers of NBCs America’s Got Talent also did a different rendition of Toxic via piano:

Unfortunately for Jake it didn’t get him through the quarterfinals.

Which do you prefer?